Cooling Systems Compared: Inverter AC vs Fixed Speed AC - Which One Should You Choose?

Figure 1: Inverter AC compressors.

Air conditioning systems have become an essential part of our daily lives, providing relief from the oppressive heat and humidity of summer. However, with so many different types of air conditioning systems available, it can be challenging to determine which one is right for your home or office.

Two of the most popular choices are inverter air conditioners (inverter AC) and fixed speed air conditioners (fixed speed AC). In this article, we will compare inverter air conditioners vs. fixed speed air conditioners and help you decide which one is right for you.

1. Fixed Speed ACs

Fixed speed air conditioners, also known as conventional air conditioners, non inverter ACs, are the most commonly used type of air conditioning system. These units have a compressor that operates at a fixed speed, which means that the compressor motor runs at a constant speed regardless of the cooling demand. The compressor is responsible for compressing the refrigerant gas, which is then circulated through the system to cool the air.

Figure 2: Mitsubishi fixed speed AC compressor.

1.1 Pros of Fixed Speed ACs

Cost-effective: Fixed speed air conditioners are generally more affordable than inverter air conditioners, making them a popular choice for those on a tight budget.

Simple mechanical components: These units have simple mechanical components that are easy to maintain and repair.

Proven technology: Fixed speed air conditioners have been around for a long time and have a proven track record of reliability.

1.2 Cons of Fixed Speed ACs

Less energy-efficient: Fixed speed air conditioners consume more energy than inverter air conditioners since they run at a constant speed even when the cooling demand is low.

Temperature fluctuations: Fixed speed air conditioners are not as precise in controlling temperature as inverter air conditioners. They tend to cycle on and off, leading to temperature fluctuations in the room.

Loud operation: The compressor motor runs at a fixed speed and produces a constant noise level, which can be disruptive and annoying.

2. Inverter ACs

Figure 3: Principle diagram of inverter air conditioner.

Inverter air conditioners, also known as variable speed air conditioners, are a newer technology that has gained popularity in recent years. These units use a variable speed compressor motor that adjusts its speed based on the cooling demand. As a result, they can operate at different speeds and adjust the cooling output to match the temperature in the room.

2.1 Pros of Inverter ACs

Energy-efficient: Inverter air conditioners are more energy-efficient than fixed speed air conditioners since they adjust the speed of the compressor motor based on the cooling demand. This leads to significant energy savings and lower electricity bills.

Precise temperature control: Inverter air conditioners can maintain a more consistent temperature in the room since they can adjust the cooling output to match the temperature in the room.

Quiet operation: Inverter air conditioners operate at a lower noise level since the compressor motor adjusts its speed based on the cooling demand.

Figure 4: AC outdoor unit inverter control board.

2.2 Cons of Inverter ACs

Higher initial cost: Inverter air conditioners are generally more expensive than fixed speed air conditioners due to the advanced technology they use.

Complex technology: Inverter air conditioners have more complex mechanical components, which can make them more challenging to maintain and repair.

Compatibility issues: Inverter air conditioners may not be compatible with older homes or buildings that do not have the necessary wiring or electrical infrastructure.

Figure 5: Hitachi central air conditioning inverter compressor.

3. Differences between an Inverter AC and a Fixed Speed AC

Inverter air conditioners and fixed speed air conditioners are two different types of air conditioning systems. While both types of air conditioners are designed to cool the air in a room or building, they operate in different ways and offer different benefits. Here are some of the key differences between them.

Energy Efficiency
One of the most significant differences between inverter air conditioners and fixed speed air conditioners is their energy efficiency. Inverter air conditioners use a variable frequency drive (VFD) to adjust the speed of the compressor motor, allowing it to operate at different speeds based on the cooling demand of the room. This means that inverter air conditioners consume less energy and can maintain a more consistent temperature.
In contrast, fixed speed air conditioners turn their compressors on and off to maintain the desired temperature, which can be less energy-efficient.

Figure 6: Contrast chart between fixed speed and variable speed compressors.

Cooling Performance
Inverter air conditioners can provide more precise temperature control than fixed speed air conditioners. The variable speed compressor motor in an inverter air conditioner can adjust its output to match the cooling demand of the room, providing consistent cooling performance. In contrast, fixed speed air conditioners can have temperature fluctuations, as the compressor turns on and off to maintain the desired temperature.

Noise Level
Inverter air conditioners are typically quieter than fixed speed air conditioners. The variable speed compressor motor in an inverter air conditioner operates at lower speeds, producing less noise than the fixed speed compressor in a traditional air conditioner.

Lifespan
Inverter air conditioners can have a longer lifespan than fixed speed air conditioners. The variable speed compressor motor has reduced wear and tear on the system, which can extend lifespan for the inverter air conditioner.

Cost
Inverter air conditioners are typically more expensive than fixed speed air conditioners. The advanced electronics and sensors used in the inverter air conditioner can increase the cost of the system. However, inverter air conditioners can save you money in the long run by reducing your electricity bills.

Maintenance
Inverter air conditioners can be more complex to repair and maintain than fixed speed air conditioners. The advanced electronics and sensors in the inverter air conditioner require specialized knowledge and skills to repair and maintain.

Table 1: Conventional AC vs inverter AC.

In summary, inverter air conditioners are more energy-efficient, provide more precise temperature control, are quieter, and can have a longer lifespan than fixed speed air conditioners. However, they can be more expensive and require more complex maintenance. Fixed speed air conditioners are less expensive and easier to maintain, but they can be less energy-efficient and provide less precise temperature control.

4. Which One is Right for You?

Choosing between an inverter air conditioner and a fixed speed air conditioner depends on your specific needs and budget. If you are looking for an affordable and straightforward cooling solution, a fixed speed air conditioner may be the right choice for you.
However, if you prioritize energy efficiency, precise temperature control, and quiet operation, an inverter air conditioner may be the better option.

4.1 Factors to Consider

Cooling needs: The size of your room, the number of occupants, and the climate in your area are essential factors to consider when choosing between an inverter air conditioner and a fixed speed air conditioner.

Energy efficiency: If you are concerned about energy consumption and want to lower your electricity bills, an inverter air conditioner may be the better choice.

Noise level: If you are sensitive to noise or have young children or pets in the house, you may want to consider an inverter air conditioner, which operates at a lower noise level.

Long-term costs: While fixed speed air conditioners may be cheaper to purchase initially, they may end up costing you more in the long run due to their higher energy consumption.

Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on your specific needs and budget. Consider your cooling needs, energy efficiency, noise level, and long-term costs before making a decision.

Related Info